Return to Archive


 
Substance Online Edition-March 2002 Contact Who We Are Search Links Front Page
  Return to Article Index

 
 

Chicago Tribune endorses Vallas while they sue school system to obtain data that Vallas illegally withheld

By George Schmidt

In endorsing Vallas for Governor, the Tribune editorial board praised Vallas for his “vision, honesty, smarts, and diligence.” At the same time, the Tribune’s lawyers were pursuing litigation to obtain detailed data about student truancy in the school system that Vallas had repeatedly denied them. According to legal briefs filed in Chicago Tribune Company v. Board of Education of the City of Chicago, the Tribune filed a request for this truancy data under the Illinois Freedom of Information Act in December 1999.
This request was denied by the school system’s “freedom of information officer,” and this denial was appealed to the “head of the public body” (Paul Vallas). Again, the request was denied, and the Tribune sued to gain the information. In September 2001, the Chicago Tribune won this case in state court. However, the Chicago Board appealed this loss, and the case is now before an appellate court. Thus, Vallas has been at the center of this multi-stage effort to resist the Tribune’s information request.
The Tribune is not alone in being stiffed in requesting information from Vallas. Hundreds of freedom of information requests from Substance, from other media, and from non-profit groups have been routinely denied or ignored by the Vallas administration. Information that was customarily available in the past was no longer released under Vallas. Thus, it became impossible, for example, to obtain financial information detailed enough to uncover deceptive budgeting practices.
Another measure of Vallas’ penchant for controlling information was his practice of having the remarks of speakers in the public participation period at Board of Education meetings eliminated from the televised version of the Board meeting, if the speakers were especially critical of him or of the Board.